If you’ve ever cleared out your closet or hunted for a hidden gem on a budget, chances are you’ve walked into a consignment or thrift store. But while these two shopping experiences might look similar on the surface, they’re actually quite different — both in how they work and what you’ll find inside.
Whether you're looking to shop more sustainably or make some money off your gently loved pieces, understanding the difference between consignment and thrift is key. Let's break it down.
What Is a Thrift Store?
Thrift stores (think Goodwill or Salvation Army) are usually nonprofit-run donation centers. People donate their clothing, furniture, and household goods, and the store sells them at affordable prices. The proceeds typically support charitable causes or community programs.
What You’ll Find:
- A wide variety of items — everything from vintage coats to quirky mugs
- Heavily donated inventory (which may mean a bit of digging!)
- Very low prices, ideal for budget-conscious shoppers
- More wear-and-tear, with less curation
What Is a Consignment Store?
Consignment stores (like Common Threads) sell items on behalf of individuals. When you consign something, the store agrees to sell it for you, and you earn a percentage of the sale price once it sells.
These shops tend to be more curated and focused on style, quality, and seasonality.
What You’ll Find:
- Gently used, often high-quality or designer items
- Clothing that’s in-season and on-trend
- A boutique shopping experience
- Higher prices than thrift — but still far below retail
So... Which Is Better?
That depends on what you're looking for.
| Goal | Best Option |
|---|---|
| Want to declutter & donate quickly? | Thrift store |
| Want to earn money for your clothes? | Consignment |
| Love the thrill of the hunt? | Thrift store |
| Prefer curated, stylish finds? | Consignment |
| Looking for designer deals? | Consignment |
| Want to support a nonprofit cause? | Thrift store |
Why Not Both?
There’s no rule that says you can’t do both — many of our customers at Common Threads consign what holds value and donate the rest. It's a great way to declutter sustainably, give your items a second life, and make room for new favorites in your wardrobe.
Quick Tip: What to Consign vs. What to Thrift
Consign:
- Designer or premium brands (think: Vince, Free People, Frye, Patagonia)
- Items in excellent condition
- Seasonal clothing
- Gently worn shoes or handbags
- Thrift/Donate:
- Fast fashion or unbranded basics
- Well-loved pieces with wear
- Items not in season
- Things you want gone quickly, no matter the return
Final Thoughts
Whether you're a seasoned secondhand shopper or just beginning your sustainable fashion journey, knowing the difference between consignment and thrift shopping helps you make smarter, more conscious decisions.
At Common Threads, we believe in both — we consign the best and donate the rest to trusted local nonprofits. It’s part of how we keep fashion circular, affordable, and community-focused.
Curious about consigning with us? Learn how it works here →